Showing posts with label Short termism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Short termism. Show all posts

Monday, January 19, 2009

Short Termism and Pricing

With the thoughts of my last article on charities and their short-termist marketing ploys in mind, my German guest poster Jo has come up with some anti-short termism thoughts of his own.


Well, we are still somewhere in the turmoil, crisis whatever you want to call it. Like most of the times people and firms react different to pressure. Today’s post is going to have a look at inappropriate short-term focus. An industry which has caused a lot of bewilderment in my eyes in the last years is the US car industry. It is one of those, most affect by the crisis, but there’s more. Beside inappropriate product portfolios and missed trends, the US carmakers have been gone completely crazy with discounting to prevent the erosion of their market share on their home market.


You want to see what I am talking about, well let’s examine a case. Take GM for instance:


“A 2007 Chevrolet Tahoe will have an MSRP of $33,990 for a model with a 5.8-liter, V-8 engine. That is $2,000 below the 2006 Chevrolet Tahoe even though the new Tahoe offers better fuel economy.”


First obvious question, why do you offer a product at a reduced price when it offers more value to the end customer?!
Anyway, just to show what this 5.6% price cut from the 06 to 07 model implies. Let’s assume they sell 1000 cars, and made a profit on each car of 3000 USD (a very positive assumption, in fact GM actually lost (!!!) some money on certain models). The graph below shows what this short-term, market share orientated marketing move means for the bottom line:
The graphs show that GM will have to sell 3000 (!!!) cars to just make the same profit as before. Amazing, right, what do you think a 5,6% price cut will you boost your sales by 200%? I simply don’t and even worse you ruin your long-term profits and prospects. This is how the fall of America’s car industry started. Well see where it goes, or well maybe their competitive strategy is more like this:
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj54MzX0uxBHeh3qyMur0rPqDAP7NG7pJV_ag_L6oE5W-O55o_jzUMJLa2mIHRsMIYYVjD2C6Kd_FLQ6cs_uFHPGORXwuJ_wGZxO0xtHOdh9GggYYqXqsY6AHRBMfwEmx0281yg-vviayX9/s1600-h/Bailout_Advert.jpg

Saturday, January 17, 2009

OverFishing - Charities and long term image

*Doorbell rings*
Ed: Hello? (seeing its a representative of Concern)
Man: Oh hello I was just wondering if you would like to support... (launches into what would inevitably be a long drawn out spiel)
Ed: Listen, thanks for coming around but I won’t waste your time (implying go away)
Man: Oh I see, what’s the matter, you don’t like Concern?
Ed: Gives angry stare and shuts the door*
...
...

The last few years have seen the major charitable organisations in Ireland turn to somewhat questionable methods in order to gain the most revenue they can, and I suppose the change represents a shift to a more “Target driven” culture in these organisations.


The most visible and hideously annoying example of this are the representatives that hit the streets and harass the public (with often questionable methods) to “take a few minutes” of our time to be bullied into giving a standing order to the charity in Question. The shift has been a very definite move towards contracting out private firms, who pay their reps €13 an hour to pester the public, and is something find a little disturbing to be honest, and I’m not sure is particularly in line with the spirit of “charitable” donations.

With consumer confidence extremely low, and many people either feeling, or fearing the consequences of the economic downturn, I would imagine that those who might have given money to a charity in better times will reconsider this. As a consequence I think this will lead to a rise in the level of the “aggressive” approach of gaining revenue.

And to be fair, it will probably work, pester people a little bit harder and they may pay up, however I think that the conduct of these charities, and what their marketing managers consider to be acceptable marketing practices are ultimately going to be harmful in the long run. By annoying/infuriating large sections of the public I think they are ensuring that they person will have a negative view of that charity in the long run, and in turn will be unlikely to donate money to them.

I like to think that the situation is similar to the problem of over fishing, you will get good returns now, but one or two years down the line what have you done to your market/fish stocks. The way things are going I think most of the major charities will have tarnished their images substantially and will regret the “hard selling” conducted during the tougher times.

Saturday, September 15, 2007

Child of Vision

I had my first class in strategic marketing this week and I must say it was a bit of an eye opener.
The first topic that our lecturer explained to us was the growing problem of short termism in major companies, and how quarterly/annual profit levels are paramount on the agenda and are prioritised above safeguarding the long term health and effectiveness of the brand in question.

The current situation that Irish drink producer C&C find themselves in was highlighted as being a perfect example of such short term thinking. C&C is the company behind the cider "Bulmers" in Ireland and "Magners" in the UK, and up until recently was involved in the production of variety of soft drinks most of which fell under the "Club" range.
However C&C decided that their soft drink range was not offering quite the same profit margin or growth potential as the growing cider market in the UK and Ireland, so sold off their soft drink division earlier this year, placing all their eggs in a very much cider dependant basket.

Cider is a product that has great seasonal fluctuations, it is a summer drink and very much marketed by the company as being so. If you live in Ireland or the UK you may have noticed that this has been one of the worst summers in the past few decades, and sales of cider predictably fell considerably.
On top of the bad weather, the competition in the Cider marketing has been heating up with competitors such as Kopperberg and Bulmers (confusingly and entirely separate brand owned by a Scottish company) stealing market share from C&C at an alarming rate.

Having sold off their soft drinks division they now have no form of fall back, and what may have at the time been a profitable decision has now left them in a great deal of trouble with sales very much down and the company’s share price about half of what is was just after the sell off.

The American bag maker “Coach” was also briefly highlighted as a brand which had destroyed its brand image through short sighted decisions made in the pursuit of profit.
“Coach” used to enjoy a very exclusive image and in terms of fashionable bags was up there with the best of them. Then coach decided to launch a range of more affordable bags and blanket bomb retails outlets everywhere around the United States, sales for that period rocketed, however once EVERYONE had a Coach bag, they were no longer exclusive or stylish and now the brand lies in tatters.

So why is this happening? Surely someone has the sense to see that decisions such as these might impact on the long term future of the company? According to our lecturer (who is the exception to this rule and a member of several boards) the main problem is that it is extremely rare for a board of directors to contain a person from a marketing background as they are seen "to not pull their weight". However considering most companies would be crippled without effective marketing I find it particularly stupid to exclude someone who has the knowledge of how to most effectively operate and maintain the brand health.

Marketing like any other business activity requires strategic thinking, and if you start putting quarterly or annual profit goals ahead of the life long health of a company… you’re in trouble.